By Peter Ramsey

18 Apr 23

Using Dark Patterns to Overcharge for Pizza Company Logo
Dominos•9 min read•
Listen

Using Dark Patterns to Overcharge for Pizza

Using Dark Patterns to Overcharge for Pizza Featured Image

Dominos is really a technology company, that just so happens to sell pizza.

Although their stores seem to be everywhere, more than 90% of their sales are online. In other words; they're basically an online pizza retailer.

And, whilst creating a case study praising their subtle UX brilliance (this one), I stumbled across a darker side of their empire.

Dominos (and Pizza Hut) use dark patterns, UX tricks and design psychology to overcharge customers.

Forget 'Big Pharma', I'll demonstrate how (and why) 'Big Pizza' do the following:

  • ⚡️

    1. Use a 'Deal Wizard' to build trust
  • 🤯

    2. Overwhelm you with vouchers
  • 🧠

    3. Leverage UX psychology to change your behaviour
  • 💸

    4. Quietly overcharge you

Get ready for a slice of deep UX analysis.

Case study

Please rotate your device to view this slideshow

Note, this won’t work if ‘rotate: lock’ is on in your device settings.
465564
465565
465566
465567
465568
465569
465570
465571
465572
465573
465574
465575
465576
465577
465578
465579
465580
465581
465582
465583
465584
465585
465586
465587
465588
465589
465590
465591
465592
465593
465594
465595
465596
465597
465598
465599
465600
465601
465602
465603
465604
465605
465606
465607
465608
465609
465610
465611
465612
465613
465614
465615
465616
465617
465618
465619
465620
465621
465622
465623
465624
465625
465626
465627
465628
465629
465630
465631
465632
465633
465634
465635
465636
465637
465638
465639
465640
465641
465642
465643
465644
465645
465646
465647
465648
465649
465650
465651
465652
465653

👇

That’s all for the slideshow, but there’s more content and key takeaways below.

Slide 1 of 91

More UX takeaways

1. PizzaGPT

Dominos have done an excellent job at (perhaps unintentionally) using design psychology as a tool to change their customer's behaviour.

Here are three examples:

  • 😳 Hicks Law — making it harder for people to quickly choose 'the best' voucher, due to both the quantity, and how difficult it is to compare the options.

But underneath it all, you're being ripped off.

In 2021, Pizza Hut was caught in the headlines for their 'Deal Bot', which essentially does the same thing.

It's not like they're surprised it's happening. Both Pizza Hut and Domino's have been replying to Tweets about this issue for nearly a decade.

Obviously awareness helps, but inherently people are lazy.

If ChatGPT told you what it thought the best voucher code was, would you trust it?

null image

To be clear, employing dark patterns like this is not a strategy that I'd recommend, even if they do work in the short term.

Perhaps, similar to how popular celebrities often get away lightly with bad behaviour, household corporations like Dominos and Pizza Hut are big enough for consumers to be misled, without ramifications.

But a great user experience is built on trust and clarity—and for the vast majority of start-ups, that's paramount.

2. Humanising pizza

Small businesses thrive on personalisation—from handwritten notes, to the implied knowledge that you know who roasted your coffee.

Culturally, we attribute more value to independence, partly because it breaks the mould of being a faceless corporation.

Some brands, like Lush Cosmetics, have maintained this personalisation even as they've grown, by printing stickers of the person who 'made' that item.

null image

In a similar vein, Dominos has invested hundreds of millions of dollars into digital initiatives, including software and back-office technology.

And it's allowed them to humanise the preparation, baking and delivery of pizza, at scale.

When an order is sent to a store, it'll record who is on-shift, and display their name to the customer on their app.

null image

Another dumb (but easy) implementation of this bias, is that I show my face and name at the end of every Built for Mars article.

I want you to know that I researched and wrote this—not because I care for the attributed credit, but instead because it helps to remind you that I'm also just a person, often sat on a barstool in my kitchen.

3. An off-ramp

The unavoidable downfall of searching for vouchers online, is that they'll often not work.

You go into the search expecting to copy and paste a code, only to be told that it's invalid. And then you just go back and try another, repeating the process until you find an active one.

Although the pain is primarily felt by the customer, the damage is dealt to the service provider (i.e., Dominos), through the creation of a really negative cycle.

null image

And the key is that this isn't Dominos' fault—the codes may have been uploaded with unclear basket requirements, or fabricated entirely by competitors.

But how Dominos handle this is fantastic: they provide an off-ramp.

Entering an invalid coupon code, will fail (as expected), and then give you a one-click way to apply a one from their site.

null image

Retention doesn't simply mean keeping people engaged in your product, but also minimising the opportunity for distractions from others, even at a financial cost to you.

For example, if you were offering test drives of a car, would you suggest a route that takes them past a slightly nicer car showroom?

You’ve finished this study

+1

Become a BFM+ member to track your progress, create a library of content and share learnings within your team.

You’ve finished this study

Other studies picked for you

A masterclass in user activation (96% of them)

A masterclass in user activation (96% of them)

Discover the art of setting a goal and then using that to immediately create the perception of success.

The Complexity Paradox of ChatGPT, AI and UX

The Complexity Paradox of ChatGPT, AI and UX

As the underlying technology improves, interfaces like ChatGPT get harder to use. Does this explain the strategy for Apple Intelligence?

BFM+ Exclusive

Unlock all 75 case studies with BFM+

View Plans
What Audible Gets Wrong About Repeat Purchases

What Audible Gets Wrong About Repeat PurchasesPreview this content

How to create a flywheel of discovery, purchase and satisfaction that leads to repeat purchases.

All of the UX analysis on Built for Mars is original, and was researched and written by me, Peter Ramsey.

Never miss the free UX analysis

Free case studies, the moment they’re released, plus a digest of the best UX Bites every few weeks.